Federal Audit Prosecutors Seek Review of Ruling on Port of Santos Dredging Tender
Nov, 16, 2026 Posted by Gabriel MalheirosWeek 202646
The Public Prosecutor’s Office at Brazil’s Federal Court of Accounts (MPTCU) filed a request on Friday (Nov. 13) asking the court to reconsider part of its decision to uphold the disqualification of the Santos Dragagem Consortium from the Port of Santos dredging tender. The consortium, led by Brazilian company Etesco, had submitted the lowest bid for a project to deepen the port’s navigation channel.
In an opinion filed in case TC 024.321/2025-7, Deputy Prosecutor-General Paulo Soares Bugarin challenged the court’s conclusion that changes to the consortium’s membership had undermined its ability to carry out the project. He called for the case to be sent back to the Santos Port Authority (APS), which conducted the tender, so it could assess whether the consortium still meets the qualification requirements and has the resources needed to complete the work.
The prosecutors also questioned how the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) reached its decision. They argued that the court upheld the consortium’s disqualification on grounds different from those originally cited by APS, without first giving Etesco an opportunity to respond. According to the MPTCU, this violated the company’s right to due process and a fair opportunity to defend its position.
The dispute dates back to September 2025, when the Santos Dragagem Consortium submitted the lowest bid in the APS tender, at R$610 million. The port authority nevertheless disqualified the group over missing documentation, including a detailed cost breakdown and a statement of indirect costs and profit margins (BDI). The consortium subsequently submitted the documents within the deadline set by the bidding committee.
The contract instead went to Jan de Nul do Brasil Dragagem for R$619.78 million, approximately R$9.8 million more than Etesco’s bid. In January 2026, the TCU temporarily suspended the tender. When it later reviewed Etesco’s challenge, the court found that the initial disqualification over missing documentation had been excessively formalistic and that bidders had been treated inconsistently. Even so, it upheld the consortium’s exclusion, raising concerns about whether changes to its membership, including Neptune Brasil’s withdrawal, affected the reliability and feasibility of its proposal.
The MPTCU argues that the withdrawal of a consortium member is not, by itself, grounds for disqualification. Its opinion cites previous TCU rulings allowing companies to leave a consortium, provided no new members are added and the remaining participants continue to meet the original bidding requirements. Prosecutors maintain that APS’s bidding committee should be the first to determine whether the consortium still has the necessary technical expertise, financial resources and equipment to carry out the project.
The opinion also addresses the subsequent withdrawal of CHEC Dredging, a Chinese company that held a minority stake in the consortium. CHEC formally notified the parties that it was leaving the group and that its equipment would no longer be available for the project. While prosecutors acknowledge that this is a significant new development, they argue that it does not give the TCU grounds to bypass the port authority’s technical review. APS, they say, must assess the legal implications of CHEC’s withdrawal and determine whether the remaining members can still meet the tender requirements.
The dispute continued after APS signed a contract with Jan de Nul in June 2026. In August, another temporary TCU order halted authorization for the work to proceed. The initial authorization had covered only preliminary environmental licensing studies and engineering plans, with no dredgers deployed or physical work carried out in the channel. The dredging project has therefore yet to begin.
The MPTCU is now seeking a partial reversal of the earlier ruling, which would send the Port of Santos dredging tender back to APS for a fresh review of the bids and bidders’ qualifications. Prosecutors want the port authority to conduct a documented technical assessment while giving all parties an opportunity to respond. The TCU has yet to consider the request and decide whether to reopen the review.
Source: MPTCU
-
Oil and Gas
Nov, 05, 2019
0
Three pre-salt fields account for more than half of brazilian oil and natural gas production
-
Other Cargo
Oct, 11, 2023
0
Brazil’s fertilizer imports down 5.1%
-
Grains
Jun, 10, 2024
0
Itaqui Port Breaks Record of Soybean Export Operations
-
Vessel Calls
Mar, 07, 2021
0
Fewer vessel calls but higher volumes handled at Santos this year YoY
