River barge logistics

Argentine Shipping Companies Warn High Costs Are Holding Back Maritime Transport Growth

Oct, 01, 2026 Posted by Gabriel Malheiros

Week 202640

With maintenance and dredging of Argentina’s Trunk Waterway (VNT) under private management for the next two decades and debate continuing over the Cabotage Law, Argentine shipping companies say the low share of cargo moving between domestic ports is not due to a lack of capacity to grow, but rather to competitiveness problems linked to what they describe as “a hostile cost ecosystem.”

“Just as it is strategically valuable for Argentina to have one of the most extensive river systems, the Argentine merchant marine must facilitate and help guarantee efficiency and competitiveness,” the Federation of Argentine Shipping Companies (FENA) said in a letter sent to Infocampo.

“In light of recent publications promoting unrestricted deregulation of the river and maritime cabotage regime as a supposed solution to high transportation costs, the Federation warns that the country should not sacrifice a strategic link in its value chain. Instead, competitive conditions must be restored so that river and maritime transport can multiply the value added generated in Argentina,” it added.

FENA acknowledged that the limited use of river transportation and Argentina’s small share of activity on the VNT are a problem, but said determining the causes requires an analysis of the fleet available for each type of traffic, its actual utilization, cargo that has gone unserved, and exemptions from the Cabotage Law that were requested and actually denied. The federation also said operating costs need to be compared comprehensively with overland transportation alternatives.

“That is why a low share for river transportation and a lack of capacity caused by the Cabotage Law are not equivalent concepts,” the federation said. From that standpoint, FENA argues that “the limited participation of Argentine vessels on the VNT shows that the conditions for competitiveness are currently not in place.”

“Argentina, however, once had a much greater presence and gradually lost it as a result of a hostile cost ecosystem,” FENA said, questioning the idea that replacing local companies with foreign operators is the solution.

“Logistics does not become cheaper by replacing Argentine capacity with foreign capacity. It becomes cheaper by eliminating the ‘Argentine cost’ that currently limits the competitiveness of those who invest, produce and operate vessels under the national flag. Correcting these distortions will make it possible to plan more and better investments, expand installed capacity and provide a greater supply of Argentine transportation services,” the group said.

Argentine Shipping Costs Drive Competitiveness Concerns

Among the factors FENA says are behind Argentine shipping costs are labor, tax, port and regulatory expenses. On labor costs, the federation says the sector faces social security charges of 38% and collective bargaining agreements that require oversized crews. On taxation, it argues that the country’s tax structure imposes costs that foreign operators elsewhere in the region do not face.

“The government’s own assessment accompanying the latest reforms acknowledged that logistics costs are considerably higher than those of other registries,” the organization said, adding that these distortions also directly affect structural port and regulatory costs.

“The facts are compelling: the pro forma operating cost for a Kamsarmax at Argentine ports such as San Martín, San Lorenzo or Timbúes is around $300,000, compared with $70,000 or $80,000 in southern Brazil. Likewise, a mooring service costs as much as $15,000, while in Montevideo it ranges from $700 to $1,000,” FENA said.

“On top of this are disproportionate increases, such as at the Port of Bahía Blanca, which raised its dollar-denominated fees by 75% last year, as well as redundant clearances from Customs and the Coast Guard that act as bureaucratic tolls with no operational purpose. As a direct consequence of this suffocating environment, Argentina’s barge fleet on the river is now practically nonexistent,” the federation added.

FENA insists that the current lack of competitiveness does not stem from the preference granted under the Cabotage Law, but from what much of the private sector repeatedly refers to as the “Argentine cost.” The federation does not criticize those seeking alternatives to lower freight rates, but argues that the underlying analysis is flawed.

“The position of users — such as grain exporters and port terminals — in their legitimate effort to reduce freight costs is understandable. However, Argentina’s shipping industry has the know-how and capital to immediately deploy the cargo capacity that production requires, provided these distortions are corrected,” FENA said.

At the same time, the federation warned that “a deregulated opening without first addressing these asymmetries will not rebuild the merchant marine or automatically generate new investment; on the contrary, it will accelerate the disappearance of the national fleet.”

“At FENA, we share the concerns of the forestry industry, regional economies, agribusiness and all productive sectors that need to reduce their logistics costs in order to compete more effectively and export more. The difference lies not in the diagnosis, but in the solution. We believe the sustainable path is to eliminate the distortions that currently prevent the national fleet from competing, rather than replacing Argentine capacity with operators working under entirely different tax, labor and regulatory rules,” the federation said.

According to FENA, the analysis should also take into account that, far from being an obstacle, the shipping industry supports a genuinely nationwide value chain, with its operating and tax expenditures benefiting shipyards, marine repair facilities, port services and other activities throughout the country.

The industry also provides, and has the potential to expand, highly skilled employment onshore, aboard vessels, at ports, in shipbuilding and among logistics professionals.

From a geopolitical standpoint, the federation argues that maintaining a national merchant fleet helps safeguard logistics sovereignty and the continuous supply of critical inputs, preventing Argentina’s production and energy sectors from becoming exposed to international crises or to foreign operators withdrawing when global freight rates fluctuate.

“Opening cabotage, by itself, does not eliminate the real additional logistics costs. It simply allows foreign capacity to enter while operating with tax and labor asymmetries in its favor,” FENA said.

To reinforce its position, FENA also called on other sectors to support greater use of the waterway, but alongside a strong nationally flagged fleet.

“Agriculture, industry and the merchant marine share the same objective: transporting production efficiently while generating investment, employment and sustainable development for the country. Achieving this goal requires treating waterborne logistics as a matter of state policy, but the ultimate solution is not to import asymmetries. It is to bring our tax, labor, administrative and operating structure into line with those of countries that understand their merchant marine for what it truly is: an asset for generating value added for the country,” the federation said.

“As a proposal, FENA views favorably the creation of a National Logistics Competitiveness Roundtable comprising representatives of the national government, the provinces, regional economies, port terminals, the shipping industry and users of the system. Its objective would be to identify and remove the distortions that currently increase the ‘Argentine cost’ and build consensus that will allow us to develop more efficient, competitive and sustainable logistics,” the letter concluded.

Source: PortalPortuario

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.